Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Third Opinion

The dead argue about the news. You pick your side.

Israel Holds Election Amid Security Concerns and High Voter Turnout

Elections After Catastrophe: When a People Call Their Governors to Account

Israel’s first vote since the Oct. 7 attacks is not merely a contest of parties but a test of whether political power is still held on trust for the preservation of every person’s life and liberty.


A people going to the polls while a war still burns and tens of thousands lie dead is a grave spectacle. In Israel, I read, this is the first election since the attacks of Oct. 7, in which nearly 1,200 were killed and 251 carried away as hostages, and since a war in Gaza in which the Israeli military has killed more than 74,000 persons, according to figures deemed reliable by international observers. More than 31% of eligible citizens had already voted by noon, the highest midday turnout in many years. Men do not leave their business, stand in lines, and mark their choice in such numbers unless they feel that something fundamental in the commonwealth is at stake.

The issue most openly named is security: whether the government failed in its first trust, which is the protection of its people, and whether it is now conducting the war in a way that secures or endangers their future. The opposition accuses the rulers of unprecedented negligence in not preventing the 7 October attacks and of blocking an investigation into that failure. Security ministers allied with the government speak in harsh terms of Palestinians, some being reported as saying that certain inhabitants of Gaza are “not even people.” Here the question for any friend of liberty is not which faction speaks more forcibly, but whether the lives and liberties of all under power are treated as of one equal workmanship, or divided into classes of more and less human.

In my Second Treatise, I defined political power as a right of making laws with penalties, only for the public good. That definition is not a flourish; it is a test. When a coalition is described as the most right‑wing in a nation’s history, when it leans on parties whose members taunt detainees and openly dehumanize some over whom they exercise force, we must ask whether such rulers can still be presumed to aim at the public good of all, or whether they approach that arbitrary power by which some make themselves judges in their own case and in the case of their enemies too. To deny the full humanity of any group is a short step from denying that the law of nature binds one toward them.

I must also observe the scale of killing reported. If it is true that more than 74,000 have been slain by military action in Gaza, then whatever name is given to the operation, reason—the law of nature—demands a reckoning. No ruler is forbidden to use force in defense; but every ruler is forbidden to use more force than is necessary to secure his people’s safety in a lasting way, and never may he treat the lives of those beyond his borders as if there were not “enough, and as good” of natural right in them as in his own citizens. A government that repeatedly places great multitudes at risk, without candid inquiry into its own counsels, tempts the charge that it has broken the very trust for which it was set up.

There are further signs of strain in this trust. The current leadership, it is said, faces an ongoing trial on corruption charges and has pressed for judicial reforms that many regard as threats to democracy, provoking mass protests even before the present war. The opposition now says that an honest investigation into the security failure is being blocked. I will not pass sentence on matters of fact I cannot examine. Yet I note the pattern they allege: a ruler seeking to weaken the impartial judge, then to shield his own actions from scrutiny, all while claiming to be the unique guardian of safety. When the same hands that wield the sword also strive to bend or unmake the courts that should judge them, a commonwealth is already far on the road from government by settled law to government by men.

At the same time, the extraordinary turnout shows that society itself is far from dissolved. In the Second Treatise I argued that the dissolution of a particular government is not the dissolution of the people; they may, without falling into chaos, appoint new trustees of their power when the old have forfeited it by a long train of abuses. High participation suggests that many citizens, Jews and Arabs alike, believe that the ballot still offers a remedy, and that they may replace governors without breaking the frame of their common life. That belief is precious; it is the chief argument against any resort to an appeal to heaven by force while civil means remain open.

Still, the right to choose new rulers is not, by itself, an absolution of the old. Consent today does not wash away violations of the law of nature yesterday. In my Essay Concerning Human Understanding, I urged that assent should follow evidence; to believe beyond proof is folly, not virtue. So here, men must proportion their political confidence to what can be known: did the government take all care to prevent the attacks; does it now wage war with rigor bounded by reason; has it respected the independence of the courts and allowed impartial inquiry? If, after sober examination, the people judge that their rulers have ceased to act for the preservation of their lives, liberties, and estates, then they not only may but must use this election to withdraw that trust. A society that can change its governors without blood need not endure governors who forget why they were trusted at all.

From the works cited

  • Second Treatise of Government — Political power defined narrowly as the right to make laws, with penalties, only for the public good — anything beyond that definition must justify itself or stand condemned.
  • Second Treatise of Government — The dissolution of a government is not the dissolution of society: a people can replace a broken legislative without descending into chaos. Fear of disorder is therefore no argument for enduring tyranny — but revolution answers only to 'a long train of abuses' tending the same way, not to every private grievance.
  • An Essay Concerning Human Understanding — Assent must be proportioned to the evidence; believing beyond one's proofs is a failure of duty, not a mark of faith.