Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Third Opinion

The dead argue about the news. You pick your side.

Egyptian court refers Mada Masr case to trial amid media crackdown

When Governments Fear Newspapers More Than Poverty

Egypt’s effort to wipe out one of its last independent newsrooms reveals a ruling interest willing to tax truth itself, and to spend the nation’s moral capital for the comfort of its own security services.


A government that fines an editor three million pounds and closes her newspaper declares, as plainly as any manifesto, what it most fears. In Egypt, we are told, Lina Attalah has been punished and Mada Masr shut, in what observers describe as a shift from mere harassment of independent media to an attempt to wipe them out altogether. This is, remarkably, the sixth case against that outlet in as many years, but the first of this particular, more serious kind to reach trial. Such perseverance by the authorities is not explained by caprice; when power returns again and again to the same small newsroom, the true object of anxiety is not the building but the public it might enlighten.

When I argued in The Wealth of Nations that we must trace every regulation to who gains and who pays, I had chiefly in view restraints upon trade; yet the same method serves for restraints upon speech. The visible beneficiaries here are close at hand: security agencies, senior officials, the entrenched interests whose conduct most needs scrutiny. Their gain is protection from embarrassment and from the slow erosion of authority that follows repeated exposure to inconvenient fact. The cost is scattered, silent, and borne by millions: citizens deprived of one of the few channels by which they might know what is done in their name, small traders and labourers who must plan their affairs in darkness, and even honest magistrates whose judgments are less trusted because no independent eye reports upon them.

In commercial policy I long ago learned to distrust the merchants’ petition, which so often dresses up a demand for monopoly as a plea for the public good. Here the role of the merchant is played by the state itself. Its petition is security; its language is that of plots, conspiracies, and the need to preserve order. But when the remedy for supposed intrigue is not the open refutation of falsehoods, but the closing of presses and the fining of editors, we see the structure of interest too clearly to be deceived by its rhetoric. A producer of narratives is striving to exclude rivals, to keep a monopoly in the manufacture of the national story, and to establish, not a free competition of arguments, but a tariff wall against criticism.

In The Theory of Moral Sentiments I asked my readers to consult the impartial spectator, that imagined onlooker who is at once well-informed and disinterested. Let us submit this policy to his tribunal. He would see a small group of writers working under the constant threat of legal harassment, now finally struck with a blow heavy enough to alarm every remaining independent voice in the country. He would observe that these writers accept personal risk to serve what they take to be the public’s right to know, while their accusers act with the whole apparatus of the state at their back. I cannot think he would judge it praise-worthy that the strong employ courts and fines, not to redress injury, but to pre-empt the possibility of being found out.

Some will reply that the state has, as I myself maintained, the first duty of defence; that a country menaced by disorder or foreign intrigue cannot afford the luxury of unbridled speech. This argument would have weight if the offending newspaper had been shown to incite violence or to betray military counsels. Yet what is reported is not a single sudden abuse met promptly, but a long train of six proceedings in six years, capped by a decisive attempt to extinguish a troublesome voice. A policy that rests, not upon the occasional punishment of clearly injurious acts, but upon the standing intimidation of critics, does not seek security in the strict sense; it seeks the quiet of uncontradicted rule.

Nor should we neglect the economic character of such measures. Information is as necessary to industry as roads or harbours. When the labouring poor must guess at the design of those who tax them, regulate them, and police them, their capacity to plan, to invest their scant savings, and to combine for lawful purposes is diminished. The rich and well-connected, who can always discover what they need by private correspondence and personal acquaintance, suffer little; the poor, who rely on the printed page accessible to all at once, bear almost the whole burden. To suppress independent media is thus to levy a tax upon the weakest, payable, not in coin, but in ignorance.

A wise legislator, conscious of his own fallibility, will sometimes err on the side of permitting what he dislikes, rather than forbidding what he does not fully understand. The Egyptian authorities, by moving from sporadic harassment to the attempted erasure of one of their last critical outlets, display the confidence, not of virtue, but of the man of system who imagines that society is a chess-board and its people passive pieces. They will, no doubt, purchase a season of fearful silence. They will also degrade the administration of justice, discourage every generous spirit among their youth, and teach their citizens that power dreads inspection. It is an unwise bargain, in which a narrow interest gains a short repose at the expense of the country’s long-run honour and opulence.

From the works cited

  • An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations — The critique of mercantilism: wealth is not money; policies rigged by merchants and manufacturers sacrifice the consumer to the producer.
  • An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations — Trace every policy to its effect on the price system and ask who bears the unseen cost: benefits are visible and concentrated, costs are diffuse and quiet.
  • The Theory of Moral Sentiments — Judge conduct by the impartial spectator: what would a well-informed, disinterested observer feel about this action? Praise-worthiness matters more than praise; to be loved without being lovely is worth nothing, and to be blamed unjustly stings less than to deserve blame.