Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Third Opinion

The dead argue about the news. You pick your side.

Legal and Political Disputes Surround Alaska Senate Race and Ballot Counting

Decoy Candidates and the Corruption of the Political Market

When campaigns toy with voters’ confusion by recruiting namesakes as spoilers, they do not compete; they collude against the public, and the impartial spectator turns away in disgust.


The spectacle from Alaska is at once novel in its details and drearily familiar in its spirit. In a closely watched Senate race, it is alleged that operatives backing one candidate helped recruit a retired schoolteacher who happens to share the name of the incumbent, placing a second version of that name upon the ballot in hopes that some citizens, hurried or inattentive, might choose the wrong one. Governors denounce, national parties seize upon the controversy, newspapers parade text messages and finance records, and lawyers debate whether criminal charges are possible. Yet beneath this bustle of accusation and counter‑accusation lies a simpler question: what kind of competition is it that endeavours to win, not by persuasion, but by the voter’s mistake?

When I wrote of markets in my inquiry into the wealth of nations, I praised not cunning but the orderly cooperation that arises when each man pursues his own interest under known rules of justice. The trader may strive to undersell his rival, but he must deliver the cloth he has promised, of the weight and fineness his customer expects. Here, however, the political entrepreneur is said to have discovered a cheaper expedient: to alter, not the quality of his own wares, but the clarity of the label on the shelf. To procure a second candidate with the same name is rather like persuading the magistrate to permit two different weights stamped alike; the buyer thinks he receives one measure, but in truth receives another.

In such cases we see how self‑love, when insufficiently restrained by regard to the rules of fair dealing, ceases to be a coordinating force and becomes a principle of corruption. Campaigns are like merchants in this respect: they are paid in votes instead of money, but they receive their reward only if they gain custom. It is therefore no matter of wonder that some, when tempted, will prefer artifice to honest industry. As I once observed of men of the same trade, their contrivances frequently end in a conspiracy against the public. To narrow electoral competition by smuggling a spoiler onto the ballot is only another form of that ancient inclination, adapted to the commerce of power instead of pins.

The visible benefit of such stratagems is highly concentrated. If the ploy succeeds, one candidate keeps a seat in the Senate, another is turned away, the leaders of one party rejoice, and the funds of one set of supporters rise in value. The costs, by contrast, are diffuse, silent, and enduring. Each confused voter who mis‑marks a ballot suffers a small private injustice that will never be individually repaired. The integrity of the ranked‑choice system, already contested in that state, is further discredited, perhaps even overturned at a later vote, not because it fails as an institution, but because it has been fouled in practice. What the triumphant campaign gains in one autumn, the public may pay for in every election thereafter.

In my moral sentiments I urged that we judge our conduct as if under the eye of an impartial spectator, well informed and free from our private partialities. Let us suppose such a spectator, standing in the polling place, observing a citizen who believes himself to support one man and in fact supports another, placed there by design. Would our spectator applaud the ingenuity of the stratagem, or feel a sharper indignation at the coolness with which the contrivers exploit the voter’s trust? Even if the law, as at present written, should fail to condemn this practice explicitly, the conscience of an upright onlooker would, I think, pronounce it a species of fraud upon the public faith, differing more in its theatre than in its essence from other impostures.

Yet we should misread human affairs if we imagined this fault peculiar to one party, one candidate, or even one country. Wherever the prize of power is valuable and the rules uncertain, men will try the experiment of winning by confusion rather than by conviction. Those who today call for prosecutions, or decry "unwarranted federal interference" while bringing their own suits in the name of electoral integrity, are themselves subject to the same temptation tomorrow. This is why, when I cautioned against the man of system in politics, I did not thereby absolve the partisans who treat the great chess‑board of society as an arena for tricks and feints. The vice is general; the colours on the campaign poster merely change its livery.

What then is required is neither a grand new scheme, nor a despairing acceptance of knavery as the inevitable price of liberty, but the humbler work of rule‑making and disclosure. The public must know who recruits candidates, who pays them, and with what design, so that the invisible hand which often leads private pursuits toward public good is not forced, in this instance, to grope through a fog of contrivance. Laws that forbid the deliberate manipulation of names and likenesses on the ballot, if narrowly drawn and impartially applied, would protect, not the interest of one party, but the common interest in a political competition where victory is earned by argument plainly stated and honestly avowed. A society that treats its voters as marks in a confidence game will soon find it has citizens fit for nothing better.

From the works cited

  • An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations — The critique of mercantilism: wealth is not money; policies rigged by merchants and manufacturers sacrifice the consumer to the producer.
  • The Theory of Moral Sentiments — Judge conduct by the impartial spectator: what would a well-informed, disinterested observer feel about this action? Praise-worthiness matters more than praise; to be loved without being lovely is worth nothing, and to be blamed unjustly stings less than to deserve blame.