Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Third Opinion

The dead argue about the news. You pick your side.

The story

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Trump Criticizes Former Lawyer Alina Habba Mildon's $50 Million Deal

Trump Criticizes Former Lawyer Alina Habba Mildon's $50 Million Deal
Photo: Al Jazeera

President Donald Trump criticized his former lawyer Alina Habba Mildon for signing a contract reportedly worth over $50 million with the family of a Venezuelan banker whom Trump later pardoned. Trump described the deal as "obnoxious and outrageous" during a Halloween party at Mar-a-Lago in Florida, stating that such work related to seeking a pardon was "not acceptable." Mildon, who signed the contract while working at the Justice Department before the pardon was granted, has denied ever being paid to obtain a pardon, discussing one with White House or Justice Department officials, or working to secure a pardon for anyone.

Sourcesthehill.comnytimes.comaljazeera.comreason.compbs.org

The takes

  • Portrait of Adam Smith

    Adam Smith

    1723–1790, Scotland (the Scottish Enlightenment: Kirkcaldy, Glasgow, Edinburgh)

    A $50 Million Pardon and the Price of Public Trust

    When a government lawyer signs a fortune-sized contract with the family of a man seeking mercy from that same government, the real commodity at sale is confidence in equal justice.

    The scene, I am told, was festive: a Halloween gathering in a Florida mansion, masks on faces and, it seems, also on motives. There, a president publicly condemned as “obnoxious” and “not acceptable” a contract exceeding $50 million, signed by one of his former lawyers with the family of a Venezuelan banker who later received his pardon. The lawyer insists she was never paid to obtain a pardon, never discussed one with the government, never worked to secure such a favour. Perhaps every word is literally true. Yet when a public official, employed at the department that helps administer justice, enters such a bargain with a supplicant for mercy, the impartial spectator already knows enough to blush.

    Read the essay
  • Portrait of John Locke

    John Locke

    1632–1704, England (writing amid the Exclusion Crisis and the Glorious Revolution)

    A $50 Million Shadow Over the Pardon Power

    When the king’s ancient prerogative is sold, or appears to be for sale, it ceases to be a remedy and becomes the very arbitrary power it was meant to restrain.

    That a single lawyer’s contract should be worth more than $50 million would be remarkable in any age; that it is agreed with the family of a man seeking a presidential pardon, while she holds posts in the Justice Department, and is followed in time by a pardon to that family’s bank, makes it something more than remarkable. I read that the former president himself now calls this arrangement “obnoxious and outrageous,” and declares it “not acceptable.” I gladly leave the weighing of particular persons to an impartial judge. But I cannot pass over in silence what this story reveals about the pardon power itself, and the trust on which all political power stands.

    Read the essay
  • Portrait of Niccolò Machiavelli

    Niccolò Machiavelli

    1469–1527, Florence (republican secretary and diplomat, then exile, amid the Italian Wars)

    Trump, the $50 Million Lawyer, and the Price of Half-Measures

    By condemning his ex-lawyer’s pardon deal as “obnoxious and outrageous,” Trump defends his image but not his institutions—and that is how a republic corrodes itself in plain sight.

    A president at a costume party denounces his former lawyer; this is already a good Florentine scene. In Florida, at a Halloween event, President Trump calls Alina Habba Mildon’s alleged $50 million contract tied to a Venezuelan banker’s pardon “obnoxious and outrageous” and “not acceptable.” The New York Times has reported on the contract; other outlets repeat the story. Habba Mildon replies that she never took money to obtain a pardon, never discussed a pardon with the White House or the Justice Department, never worked to secure one. The effect is not edifying: a president fuming in public, a former confidante protesting, and a vast sum of money dangling between them like a chandelier about to fall.

    Read the essay