Three Killed and Seven Injured in Shooting at Idaho In-N-Out Restaurant

The takes

• 

  Adam Smith

  1723–1790, Scotland (the Scottish Enlightenment: Kirkcaldy, Glasgow, Edinburgh)

  What a Shooting at a Burger Shop Reveals About Justice and the Market

  A gunman in a drive-thru lane does more than spill blood; he shrinks the extent of the market and lays bare the state’s first duty, and its temptations, in the aftermath.

  A man with a rifle stepping from the drive-thru of a newly opened burger shop, three people killed and others grievously wounded in an ordinary afternoon of eating and errands: the very plainness of the scene in Twin Falls is what should most alarm us. When I wrote, in my moral work, of spectators who sympathise with the fortunes of others, I did not imagine sympathy would be asked to stretch itself to such frequent spectacles of sudden slaughter in places of common resort. Here the impartial spectator requires no delicate casuistry: the gunman’s conduct is not merely imprudent or irregular, but a direct assault upon the very possibility of living together in peace.

  Read the essay →
• 

  John Locke

  1632–1704, England (writing amid the Exclusion Crisis and the Glorious Revolution)

  A Burger Shop in a State of War

  The Idaho shooting is not a mystery of motives but a plain violation of natural law, and it reminds us what government is for — and what it is not.

  A man steps from a drive‑thru with an AR‑style rifle, three people are killed and seven wounded, a new restaurant in Twin Falls is turned in an instant from a house of ordinary labour into a scene of slaughter. Police find the suspected gunman dead nearby; hospitals and law enforcement “work closely” to manage the aftermath. The president of the company says her heart is broken. I begin there, not with abstractions, because this is how political philosophy properly starts: with lives cut short, with injuries to flesh and spirit, with the tangible ruin of families who ordered a meal and instead received a wound.

  Read the essay →
• 

  Niccolò Machiavelli

  1469–1527, Florence (republican secretary and diplomat, then exile, amid the Italian Wars)

  A Burger, a Rifle, and the Bankruptcy of the Middle Course

  The Twin Falls shooting is not an inexplicable horror but a predictable verdict on leaders who trust luck, pieties, and thin institutions against armed appetites.

  An In-N-Out stands open one week in Twin Falls, and already three citizens lie dead, seven injured, the gunman himself among the bodies. A witness sees a man with an AR‑style rifle emerge from the drive‑thru. Police later find the suspected shooter dead near the restaurant. The hospital says it is working closely with law enforcement; the governor calls for prayers; the company president says her heart is broken. All this is human and even honorable as private feeling. But the effectual truth is simpler and harder: an armed man decided to kill, found no barrier strong enough to stop him in time, and the state is left to count its wounded.

  Read the essay →