US Envoys Meet with Leaders in Moscow and Kyiv Amid Ongoing Drone Attacks

The takes

• 

  Adam Smith

  1723–1790, Scotland (the Scottish Enlightenment: Kirkcaldy, Glasgow, Edinburgh)

  Drones over the Black Sea, Envoys on the Train

  While hundreds of flying machines trade explosions between Russia and Ukraine, a quieter traffic in arguments and interests may yet restore the only real basis of prosperity: peace, justice, and the freedom of ordinary people to get on with their work.

  We are told that in a single night Russia launched more than a hundred long‑range drones and missiles at Ukraine, while claiming to have destroyed more than twice that number of Ukrainian drones over its own territory, Crimea, and the waters of the Black and Azov seas. Amid this traffic of destruction, at least two civilians were killed and others wounded on each side. At the same time, two envoys of the United States travelled by train to Kyiv, having just passed three hours in private conversation with Russia’s ruler in Moscow. Thus, while machines cross borders to destroy, men cross them to talk. One traffic narrows the market with fire; the other attempts, perhaps feebly, to widen it with words.

  Read the essay →
• 

  John Locke

  1632–1704, England (writing amid the Exclusion Crisis and the Glorious Revolution)

  Drone War Without Consent

  When rulers wage remote war that predictably strikes innocents, they step outside the trust of government, and the labor of peace talks becomes not diplomacy’s luxury but its urgent duty.

  While two American envoys ride the rails into Kyiv after three hours of closed talks in Moscow, drones and small missiles cross the night air in far greater numbers. We are told that one side launched 108 long‑range drones and missiles, of which 82 were brought down; the other claims to have destroyed 258 incoming drones over its own regions and occupied territories. In the midst of this exchange, at least two persons are reported killed and others grievously wounded, on both sides of the border. Thus the stage is set: men sitting in guarded rooms to discuss peace, while in the dark outside machines range abroad to deal death at a distance.

  Read the essay →
• 

  Niccolò Machiavelli

  1469–1527, Florence (republican secretary and diplomat, then exile, amid the Italian Wars)

  Drones, Envoys, and the Price of Borrowed Peace

  When 258 drones fall in the same night that envoys shuttle between Moscow and Kyiv, you are not seeing hypocrisy; you are seeing the only kind of peace negotiation that has any chance of working.

  I begin from the image, because politics is made of images: in one night, Russia says it shoots down 258 Ukrainian drones across its regions, Crimea, and nearby seas, while Ukraine reports 108 Russian drones and missiles sent the other way. At the same time, two American envoys pass from a three‑hour, closed‑door audience in the Kremlin to a train into Kyiv, where Ukrainian officials receive them and the president declares himself ready for a “substantive conversation.” Blood, metal, and polite phrases move together. To the theologian this looks monstrous; to anyone who has read history, it is simply how wars are actually ended.

  Read the essay →